Search this blog

22 January, 2011

Mythbusting: deferred rendering

Today I want to write a bit about deferred rendering and its myths. Let's go...

1) Is deferred good?

Yes, deferred is great. Indeed, you should always think about it. If for "deferred" we mean doing the right computations in the right space... You see, deferred shading is "just" an application of a very general "technique". We routinely take these kind of decisions, and we should always be aware of all our options. 

Do we do a separable, two-pass blur or a single pass one? Do we compute shadows on the objects or splat them in screen-space? What do I pass through vertices, and what through textures?

We always choose where to split our computation in multiple passes, and in which space to express the computation and its input parameters. That is fundamental!

Deferred shading is just the application of this technique to a specific problem: what we do if we have many analytic, lights in a dynamic scene? With traditional "forward" rendering the lights are constant inputs to the material shader, and that creates a problem when you don't know which lights will land on which shader. You have to start to create permutations, generate the same shader with support of different number of lights, then at runtime see how many lights influence a given object and assign the right shader variant... All this can be complicated, so people started thinking that maybe having lights as shader constants was not really the best solution.

Bear with me. Let's say that you have a forward renderer that does assign lights to objects, it's working but you're fed of it. You might start noticing that it works better if the objects are not huge and you can cap the maximum number of lights per object. In theory, the finer you can split your objects the best, you don't have too many lights overlapping a given pixel, maybe 3/4 maximum, but when the objects are large compared to the lights area of influence things start to be painful.
What would you start thinking? Wouldn't it be natural to think that maybe you can write the indices of the lights somewhere else, not in the pixel shaders constants? Well, you might think to write some indices to your lights in the pixels... here it comes the Light-Indexed Deferred Rendering.

Let's say on the other hand that in your forward renderer you really hated to create multiple shaders to support different numbers of lights per object. So you went all multipass instead. First you render all your objects with ambient lighting only, then for each extra light you render the object with additive blending feeding as input that light.
It works fine but each and every time you're executing the vertex shader again, and computing the texture blending to multiply your light with the albedo. As you add more textures, things really become slow. So what? Well, maybe you could write the albedo out to a buffer and avoid computing it so many times. Hey! Maybe I could write all the material attributes out, normals and specular. Cool. But now really I don't need the original geometry at all, I can use the depth buffer to get the position I'm shading, and draw light volumes instead. Here it comes, the standard deferred rendering approach!

So yes, you should think deferred. And make your own version, to suit your needs!

p.s. it would have been better probably to call deferred shading "image-space shading". It's all about the space the computations happen into. What will we call our rendering the day we combine virtual texture mapping (clipmaps, megatextures or what you wanna call them) with the idea of baking shading in UV space? Surface caching, I see. Well it's ok, nowadays people call globals "singletons" and pure evil "design patterns", you always need to come up with cool names.

2) Deferred is the only way to deal with many lights.
Well if you've read what I wrote above you already know the answer. No :)

Actually I'll go further than that and say that nowadays that the technique has "cooled down" there is no reason for anyone to be implementing pure deferred renderers. And if you're doing deferred chances are that you have a multipass forward technique as well, just to handle alpha. Isn't that foolish? You should at the very least leverage it on objects that are hit by a single light!

And depending on your game multipass on everything can be an option, or generating all the shader permutations, or doing a hybrid of the two, or of the three (with deferred thrown in too). Or you might want to defer only some attributes and not others, work in different spaces...

But it's not only about this kind of optimizations. You should really look at your game art and understand what its the best space to represent your lights. The latest game I shipped defers only SSAO and shadows, and I experimented with many different forms of lighting, from using analytic to spherical bases to cubemaps. And it ends up using a mix of everything...

3) Deferred is an alternative to light maps.
Not really.

Many artists came to me thinking that deferred is the future because it allows you to place lights in realtime. Well I'm telling you, with CUDA, distributed processing and so forth, if your lightmap generation is taking ages and your artists can't have decent feedback, it's a problem of your tools, not really of the lightmap technique per se.

Also deferred handles a good number of lights only if they are unshadowed point lights. So either you get a game that looks like some bad phong-shiny 3d studio 4 dos, rendering or your artists have to start placing a lot of lights with "cookies" to fake GI (and back to the 90ies we are). 

Or we will need better realtime GI alternatives... like computing light maps in realtime... Still, they are not bad, for static scenes or the static part of your scene light maps still make a lot of sense and they will always do as they are an expression of another of these general techniques: precomputation a.k.a. trading space for performance.

4) Deferred shading is slower than deferred lighting (a.k.a. light prepass).
Depends. The usual argument here is that deferred shading requires more memory than deferred lighting, thus more bandwidth, thus it's slower because deferred is bandwidth limited. It turns out that's a mix of false statements with some questionable ones.

First, it's false that deferred shading uses considerably more memory. Without going into too many details, usually deferred shading engines use four RGBA8 rendertargets plus the depth, plus a rendertarget to store the final shaded stuff. Deferred lighting needs at least a RGBA8 (normals and specular exponent) plus depth for lighting. Lighting needs to be stored into two RGBA8 to have comparable quality (some squeeze this into a single RGBA8, some use two RGBA16, it really depends on what's the dynamic range of your lights), plus you need the buffer for the final rendered stuff. So it's basically 6 32bit buffers versus 5, not such a huge difference.

Second, more memory does not imply more bandwidth. And here is where things start to be variable. Both methods are basically overdraw free in the "attribute writing" passes, as you can sort your objects front to back and use a bit of z-prepass (or even a full one if you want to compute SSAO or shadows in screenspace at that point). The geometry pass in the deferred lighting is also basically overdraw free (as the hi-z has been already primed). So what it really matters is the lighting pass. Now if you have a lot of overdraw there, you are in danger. You can decide if to be bottlenecked in the blend stage (i.e. on ps3 with deferred lighting) or in the texture one (deferred shading). Or you can decide to do the right thing and do the "tiled" variant of deferred rendering.

Last but not least, deferred might not be actually be bandwidth limited. I've seen more than one engine where things were actually ALU bound. And I've seen more than one engine struggling with vertex shading, thus being limited by the two geometrical passes deferred lighting has. 
And I'm not alone, in the end it really depends on your scene, on your platform and your bottlenecks. Deferred lighting is an useful technique but it's not a clear winner over deferred shading or any other technique.

5) Deferred lighting can express better materials than deferred shading.
Nah, not really. It's true that you have a second geometry pass where you can pass per vertex attributes and do some magic, but it turns out that the amount of magic you can perform with the lights already computed and fixed to the phong model is really little. Really little.

Also consider that deferred lighting works with a fundamental flaw, that is blending together specular contributions. It also in many implementations allow only for monochromatic "specular light".

Now there are some lighting hacks that work better with deferred lighting and some others that work better with deferred shading but in general both techniques decouple lights from objects "too late". They do it at the material parameter level, that's to say deep into the BRDF. In the end all your materials will use the very same shading model, minus some functions applied to it via lookup tables.

To the opposite end it the light-indexed technique, that decouples lighting from materials as "early" as possible, that's to say at the light attribute fetching stage. Can something be in a middle ground between the two? Maybe we could encode the lights in a way that still allows BRDF processing without needing to fetch the single analytical light attributes and integrate them one at a time? Maybe we could store the radiance instead of the irradiance... Maybe in a SH? I've heard a few discussions over this and it's in general impractical but recently Crytek managed to do something related to this in the cryEngine 2 to express anisotropic materials.

6) Deferred lighting works better with MSAA.
Yes. Sort-of.

If you don't write per sample attributes, all deferred techniques really do not work with MSAA if you don't use some care when fetching the screen space attributes, that might be a bilateral filter, the "inferred lighting" discontinuity filter or other solutions. This ends up to be the "preferred way" of doing MSAA and it's applicable to everything. And many nowadays do not MSAA at all and do a postfilter, like MLAA, instead.

Even if you just do shadows in screen space, as for example the first Crysis does, you will end up with aliasing if you don't filter (and crysis does, but the shadow discontinuities are not everywhere in the scene so it's ok-ish).

Now with DirectX 10.1 or with some advanced trickery on previous APIs you can read individual MSAA samples and decide where to compute shading per sample (instead of per pixel). That means that you will need to store all the samples in memory and keep them around for the lighting stage, as these attributes are not colors, can't be blended together in a meaningful way.

This enables you to compute and read per-sample attributes at discontinuities, and this is where deferred lighting has an advantage, as the attributes that go into the lighting stage are packed in just a single buffer so storing them per-sample requires the same amount of memory as your final buffer (and in fact it can be shared with your final buffer, as you won't need these after the lighting stage), and the lighting buffer can be MSAA-resolved as lighting will blend properly.

Doing the same with deferred shading would be a bit crazy, as you would need to store per-sample attributes of four buffers. It is possible even if really not too good to do a "manual" MSAA-resolve on the G-Buffer (thus not keeping all the samples for the lighting stage) where you do standard MSAA averaging for the albedo and use the "nearest" (to the camera) sample for the rest and it somewhat works.

Update: What they don't want you to know! :)
To close this article, I'll put here some tips and less talked about things about deferred techniques. One advantage of both deferred lighting and shading is that you get cheap decals (both "volumetric" and "standard" ones) as you don't have to compute lighting multiple times, the decals lie on a surface, so you can fetch the lighting you've already computed for it.
That of course means that the decal will need to change the surface's normals if needed blending its own, so you don't really get two separate and separately lit layers but it's still a great way to add local detail without multitexturing the whole surface...
If you think about it a second, it's the very same advantage you have with lights, you don't need to assign them per mesh thus potentially wasting computations on parts of the mesh that are not lit by a given light or need to split the mesh in complicated ways.

Also, it is neat to be able to inject some one-pixel "probes" in the gbuffer here and there, and have lighting computed on them "for free" (well... cache trashing and other penalties aside) for particles, transparencies and other effects, i.e. see the work Saints Row 3 did.

Another advantage that is especially relevant today (with tessellation...), is that you can somehow lessen the problem of non full pixel quads generated by small triangles (and the absence of quad fusion on GPUs). This is especially true of deferred shading, as it employs a single gbuffer pass that is taxing on bandwidth but less on processing (or... it could be that way). In deferred lighting you can achieve a nearly perfect culling (i.e. with occlusion queries generated during the first gbuffer pass) and zero overdraw in the second geometry pass, but you still have the quad problem...

Which unfortunately, will also affect what AMD calls "Forward plus" (and should be called light indexed deferred instead, as that's what it is... there is still research to be done on that and how to compress light information per tile, avoiding to have to store a variable light list and so on... AMD did not much there really).

132 comments:

MJP said...

I have to agree with you on point #3...there seems to be a disturbing trend of games foregoing any kind prebaked GI in favor of faking it with lots of deferred lights and nasty hacks like SSAO. I helped my coworker develop a GI baker in CUDA that uses PRT for real-time preview/light tweaking, and even with totally unoptimized code it can finish a complex scene in a few minutes on an older consumer-level GPU. It seems a lot of people just no longer want to deal with the complexity of researching, implementing, and maintaining such a system.

Also with regards to #6...you can't resolve an MSAA lighting buffer prior to sampling it in the final pass. It will cause artifacts for pixels where 1 or more triangles only cover a fraction of subsamples. During the final pass you also need to avoid sampling subsamples of the lighting pass buffer that don't "belong" to the triangle being rasterized, either by running the shader at per-sample frequency or by using SV_Coverage in D3D11.

DEADC0DE said...

MJP: Is just that some people just go with the latest trend, they switch their brain off and not think that every new technique is a tool in your arsenal but it's still up to you to use the right tools in the right places.

DEADC0DE said...

MJP: About #6 I agree that it's not really correct (at all) but I've seen that done and mhm I might be fuzzy on this but I think it does produce something reasonable.

Steve Marton said...

"So it's basically 6 32bit buffers versus 5, not such a huge difference."

Ummm... Can you go into detail on how you would lay out your buffers for light prepass?

As far as I can tell light prepass requires only one additional buffer - the light accumulation buffer - over forward rendering. Total is light buffer, final/normal buffer, depth buffer = 3 (or 4 if you need more light precision).

Since the normals/specpower are not needed after the light prepass, they can share the final buffer. Normals can be rendered into the final buffer, light buffer calculated, then normals overwritten in the final pass with the final color.

Also, light prepass avoids the annoyances associated with MRTs.

Why would anyone use deferred shading, again? :)

DEADC0DE said...

Steve: you're not going far with an 8bit light buffer, you need at least 16 or two 8 bits (diffuse and specular), i've seen games shipping with two 16 bits... So that counts for two. Also i was reasoning about bandwidth so i did not count the fact that you can save memory by shring buffs, as that won't reduce bandwidth. And i wrote it clearly in the post i think. Also i can see still a few reasons to go deferred shading, it really depends on the kind of game you're doing and how are your lights vs geometry. A game for example with dense geometry and dunno, the need to do cool decals in the gbuffer will work way better with deferred shading. Also i don't love the fact that the specular is fundamentall wrong in deferred lighting bu i didn't stud in depth was kind of visual defects that leads to

@rompa69 said...

Wrt #4, deferred lighting has to perform another vertex transform pass that happens regardless of Hi-Z, which can be expensive especially if its not a simple ModelViewProj transform. However, an advantage on some platforms is the second (colour) pass can be predicated on the visibility result of the first (depth) pass if things are drawn in the correct order.

Clustered lighting is also pretty cool as it works equally well for forward or deferred passes, but it does have a significant CPU overhead with sorting and "bucketing" a large number of lights if done in view-space.

Unknown said...

Great post and nice blog shared here.Its an beautiful Content. Keep up the good work admin and thanks for sharing this post.

Rahasia Menang Judi Online

agen fafaslot said...

Situs Fafaslot menyediakan banyak variasi permainan slot online yang mana langkah memainkan dan memenangkan amat mudah saja. Selain slot online, aplikasi ini termasuk menyediakan permainan lainnya seperti tembak ikan online, live casino dan mini games dan semuanya dapat anda mainkan bersama hanya memanfaatkan sebuah user Id saja.

FafaSlot said...


The Fafaslot site provides many variations of online slot games where steps to play and win are very easy. In addition to online slots, this application includes providing other games such as online fish shooting, live casino and mini games and you can play them together using only a user ID.

agen fafaslot
daftar fafaslot
situs fafaslot

FafaSlot said...


The Fafaslot site provides many variations of online slot games where steps to play and win are very easy. In addition to online slots, this application includes providing other games such as online fish shooting, live casino and mini games and you can play them together using only a user ID.

agen fafaslot
daftar fafaslot
situs fafaslot

FafaSlot said...

The Fafaslot site provides many variations of online slot games where steps to play and win are very easy. In addition to online slots, this application includes providing other games such as online fish shooting, live casino and mini games and you can play them together using only a user ID.

agen fafaslot
daftar fafaslot
situs fafaslot

FafaSlot said...

The Fafaslot site provides many variations of online slot games where steps to play and win are very easy. In addition to online slots, this application includes providing other games such as online fish shooting, live casino and mini games and you can play them together using only a user ID.

agen fafaslot
daftar fafaslot
situs fafaslot

FafaSlot said...

The Fafaslot site provides many variations of online slot games where steps to play and win are very easy. In addition to online slots, this application includes providing other games such as online fish shooting, live casino and mini games and you can play them together using only a user ID.

agen fafaslot
daftar fafaslot
situs fafaslot

918kiss said...

Register 918kiss to play 918kiss casino slots or online slots you can do at Depobos Indonesian online gambling agents using a local bank account.

918kiss
918kiss
918kiss

918kiss said...

Register 918kiss to play 918kiss casino slots or online slots you can do at Depobos Indonesian online gambling agents using a local bank account.

918kiss
918kiss
918kiss

918kiss said...

Register 918kiss to play 918kiss casino slots or online slots you can do at Depobos Indonesian online gambling agents using a local bank account.

918kiss
918kiss
918kiss

joker128 said...

Depobos adalah agen judi slot game dan tembak ikan online joker128 teraman dan terpercaya di asia. Depobos sebagai penyedia untuk website utamanya adalah Joker128 yang memiliki banyak permainan game slot online atau permainan Tembak Ikan online Indonesia. Yang tersedia dalam bentuk aplikasi ataupun bisa di mainkan di dekstop dengan kualitas gambar yang bagus dan jernih, kami memanjakan para pecinta game slot di Indonesia untuk bermain secara nyaman di handphone ataupun di komputer.

FafaSlot said...

The Fafaslot site provides many variations of online slot games where steps to play and win are very easy. In addition to online slots, this application includes providing other games such as online fish shooting, live casino and mini games and you can play them together using only a user ID.

Fafaslot
Fafaslot
Fafaslot

FafaSlot said...


The Fafaslot site provides many variations of online slot games where steps to play and win are very easy. In addition to online slots, this application includes providing other games such as online fish shooting, live casino and mini games and you can play them together using only a user ID.

Fafaslot
Fafaslot
Fafaslot

fafaslot said...

The Fafaslot site provides many variations of online slot games where steps to play and win are very easy. In addition to online slots, this application includes providing other games such as online fish shooting, live casino and mini games and you can play them together using only a user ID.

Fafaslot
Fafaslot
Fafaslot

FafaSlot said...

The Fafaslot site provides many variations of online slot games where steps to play and win are very easy. In addition to online slots, this application includes providing other games such as online fish shooting, live casino and mini games and you can play them together using only a user ID.

Fafaslot
Fafaslot
Fafaslot

joker118 said...

daftar joker118 sekarang juga disini, anda harus segera daftar joker118 disini karena kami agen yang memberikan jaminan membayar kemenangan anda ! Bonus yang kami berikan juga bukan sedikit, kami memberikan bonus bagi member baru 200%, bonus rebate 0,8%, tunggu apa lagi ? main sekarang juga bersama kami di sini.

joker118 said...

Daftar daftar joker118 sekarang juga disini, anda harus segera daftar daftar joker118 disini karena kami agen yang memberikan jaminan membayar kemenangan anda ! Bonus yang kami berikan juga bukan sedikit, kami memberikan bonus bagi member baru 200%, bonus rebate 0,8%, tunggu apa lagi ? main sekarang juga bersama kami di sini.

Joker88 said...

Very good post thanks for sharing it here.

Joker88
Joker88
Joker88

Joker88 said...

Thanks for sharing such a nice article I loved to read this such an amazing work.

Joker88
Joker88
Joker88

Joker88 said...

I really really appreciate this article Thanks For Sharing People also like this.

Joker88
Joker88
Joker88

Joker88 said...

Thanks for sharing such a nice article I loved to read this such an amazing work.

Joker88
Joker88
Joker88

Joker88 said...

This is really a great article and great read for me. Its my first visit to your blog and i have found it so useful and informative specially this article.

Joker88
Joker88
Joker88

joker188 said...

joker188
joker188
joker188

joker168 said...

Joker168 is an online slot gambling site that provides a variety of real money casino games and can be played through official Depobos agents. Access from Joker168 itself is very easy where you can play all the above online casino gambling games via PC, Android smartphone and iOS using a light internet connection. joker168

Unknown said...

agen joker188
agen joker188
agen joker188

Joker288 said...

If you want to Shoot Fish Gambling Register, do not hesitate to contact Whatsapp or Livechat us. Because joker288 provides Original Money Fish Shoot Gambling by several well-known providers such as CQ9, Spadegaming and joker288. The Fish Shoot game is currently very popular because it provides a very high victory rate. Of course this Fish Shoot Gambling Game gives a different sensation to you online gambling players.

agen Joker288 said...

If you want to Shoot Fish Gambling Register, do not hesitate to contact Whatsapp or Livechat us. Because agen joker288 provides Original Money Fish Shoot Gambling by several well-known providers such as CQ9, Spadegaming and agen joker288. The Fish Shoot game is currently very popular because it provides a very high victory rate. Of course this Fish Shoot Gambling Game gives a different sensation to you online gambling players.

joker234 said...

JOKER234 Agen Tembak Ikan yang menyediakan permainan Tembak Ikan Online Terbaik dengan minimal deposit dan withdraw 50 ribu rupiah. Permainan Fish Hunter jokergaming sangatlah popular saat ini dan sangat mudah di buka melalui Android maupun iOs. Selain itu Bandar Judi Tembak Ikan Joker234 juga memberikan komisi mingguan hingga 0,8% bagi para pemain Judi Ikan.

situs joker234 said...

JOKER234 Agen Tembak Ikan yang menyediakan permainan Tembak Ikan Online Terbaik dengan minimal deposit dan withdraw 50 ribu rupiah. Permainan Fish Hunter jokergaming sangatlah popular saat ini dan sangat mudah di buka melalui Android maupun iOs. Selain itu Bandar Judi Tembak Ikan Joker234 juga memberikan komisi mingguan hingga 0,8% bagi para pemain Judi Ikan.

situs joker234

Joker99 said...

Joker99 Login is an alternative link provided by a concrete online gambling agent. With an online gambling system, of course there are obstacles that all players experience are always different. But every problem there is certainly a solution, so it does not interfere with any gambling activities broo and siss with online gambling agents Depobos. Because as the best and most trusted online gambling agent, I certainly have expected all of these things.

Joker288 said...

If you want to Shoot Fish Gambling Register, do not hesitate to contact Whatsapp or Livechat us. Because Joker288 provides Original Money Fish Shoot Gambling.

Joker288
Joker288
Joker288

Joker288 said...

If you want to Shoot Fish Gambling Register, do not hesitate to contact Whatsapp or Livechat us. Because Joker288 provides Original Money Fish Shoot Gambling.

agen Joker288
agen Joker288
agen Joker288

Joker288 said...

If you want to Shoot Fish Gambling Register, do not hesitate to contact Whatsapp or Livechat us. Because Joker288 provides Original Money Fish Shoot Gambling.

daftar Joker288
daftar Joker288
daftar Joker288

Joker288 said...

If you want to Shoot Fish Gambling Register, do not hesitate to contact Whatsapp or Livechat us. Because Joker288 provides Original Money Fish Shoot Gambling.

situs Joker288
situs Joker288
situs Joker288

Situs Joker338 said...

Situs Joker338 is the most sought after online game by the people of Indonesia because it provides various Situs Joker338 slot machines and fish shooting which can be played via android or computer.

Situs Joker338

Anonymous said...

joker99 Login merupakan sebuah link alternatif yang sudah disediakan oleh agen judi online betonklik. Dengan sistem bermain judi secara online tentu ada saja kendala yang dialami setiap pemain selalu berbeda-beda. Tetapi setiap masalah tersebut pastinya ada solusinya, sehingga tidak mengganggu setiap aktivitas berjudi broo dan siss bersama agen judi online Depobos. Karena sebagai agen judi online terbaik dan terpercaya, pastinya sudah memperkirakan semua hal tersebut.

Unknown said...

joker123
joker123
joker123
joker123
joker123
joker123

joker128 said...

The world of online gambling continues to be developed with a wide selection of products such as online joker128 slot games.

joker128
joker128
joker128

joker128 said...

The world of online gambling continues to be developed with a wide selection of products such as online joker128 slot games.

joker128
joker128
joker128

judipokerqq said...

The dealer is the one who manages online poker games, with more and more people who are fond of poker more and more new dealers are appearing. Poker book listings will help you find trusted dealers that can be used as a place to play bets that are safe and comfortable. It is undeniable that players in Indonesia are very happy with a game that can make a profit. While playing bets in Indonesia is prohibited, playing online is chosen by many players so that the risk is smaller.

situs poker online
situs poker online
situs poker online

judipokerqq said...

The dealer is the one who manages online poker games, with more and more people who are fond of poker more and more new dealers are appearing. Poker book listings will help you find trusted dealers that can be used as a place to play bets that are safe and comfortable. It is undeniable that players in Indonesia are very happy with a game that can make a profit. While playing bets in Indonesia is prohibited, playing online is chosen by many players so that the risk is smaller.

situs poker online
situs poker online
situs poker online

joker168 said...

Joker168 is an online slot gambling site that provides a variety of real money casino games and can be played through official Depobos agents. Access from Joker168 itself is very easy where you can play all the above online casino gambling games via PC, Android smartphone and iOS using a light internet connection.
joker168
joker168
joker168

Situs Joker188 said...

Situs Joker188 judi slot mesin online uang asli dan live casino online terbesar di Indonesia. Agen Slot Online Situs Joker188 menyediakan ratusan permainan judi slot online terbaik dan live casino online dengan minimal taruhan yang terjangkau untuk semua kalangan yang baru bermain Slot Online Uang Asli. Selain itu kami juga menyediakan produk Taruhan Tembak Ikan Online Uang Asli.

judipokerqq said...

The dealer is the one who manages online poker games, with more and more people who are fond of poker more and more new dealers are appearing. Poker book listings will help you find trusted dealers that can be used as a place to play bets that are safe and comfortable. It is undeniable that players in Indonesia are very happy with a game that can make a profit. While playing bets in Indonesia is prohibited, playing online is chosen by many players so that the risk is smaller.

situs poker online
situs poker online
situs poker online

judipokerqq said...

The dealer is the one who manages online poker games, with more and more people who are fond of poker more and more new dealers are appearing. Poker book listings will help you find trusted dealers that can be used as a place to play bets that are safe and comfortable. It is undeniable that players in Indonesia are very happy with a game that can make a profit. While playing bets in Indonesia is prohibited, playing online is chosen by many players so that the risk is smaller.

situs poker online
situs poker online
situs poker online

joker368 said...

Selamat datang di website agen joker368 terpercaya 2020 dan semoga bettor lovers merasa nyaman dengan tampilan web Joker 368 terbaru depobos ini. Sebelumnya kami ingin memperkenalkan diri sebagai salah satu daftar situs slot online Indonesia yang telah memiliki tingkat kepercayaan tinggi. joker368

yunayui3148 said...

Selamat datang di website agen joker368 terpercaya 2020 dan semoga bettor lovers merasa nyaman dengan tampilan web Joker 368 terbaru depobos ini. Sebelumnya kami ingin memperkenalkan diri sebagai salah satu daftar situs slot online Indonesia yang telah memiliki tingkat kepercayaan tinggi. http://51.79.171.68/

Joker288 said...

Because Joker288 provides Original Money Fish Shoot Gambling by several well-known providers such as CQ9, Spadegaming and Joker288.

Joker288
Joker288
Joker288

Joker288 said...

Because Joker288 provides Original Money Fish Shoot Gambling by several well-known providers such as CQ9, Spadegaming and Joker288.

Joker288
Joker288
Joker288

Joker288 said...

Because Joker288 provides Original Money Fish Shoot Gambling by several well-known providers such as CQ9, Spadegaming and Joker288.

Joker288
Joker288
Joker288

Joker188 said...

You are really a good explained and really discussed the topic in a detailed but understandable manner. Thanks for the blog and awaiting to read more on such topics.

Joker188
Joker188
Joker188
Joker188
Joker188
Joker188
Joker188
Joker188
Joker188

Anonymous said...

Kami sebagai agen joker777 terus berupaya memberikan hiburan online yang paling profesional, menarik, dan memuaskan bagi para member setia kami, dengan layanan terbaik, penawaran permainan terbaik, dan staf yang sangat profesional di lingkungan yang aman dan nyaman. Kami menyediakan layanan agen joker777, deposit joker777, download joker777, login joker777 dan link alternatif joker777.

Anonymous said...

Kami sebagai situs joker777 terus berupaya memberikan hiburan online yang paling profesional, menarik, dan memuaskan bagi para member setia kami, dengan layanan terbaik, penawaran permainan terbaik, dan staf yang sangat profesional di lingkungan yang aman dan nyaman. Kami menyediakan layanan daftar joker777, situs joker777, download joker777, login joker777 dan link alternatif joker777.

joker388 said...

situs joker388 yang menyediakan permainan joker 388 khusus untuk para pecinta slot online adalah Joker338.

joker128 said...

The world of online gambling continues to be developed with a wide selection of products such as online joker128 slot games.

joker128
joker128
joker128

joker128 said...

The world of online gambling continues to be developed with a wide selection of products such as online joker128 slot games.

joker128
joker128
joker128

Situs Joker888 said...

DepoBos menyediakan permainan Situs Joker888 khusus untuk para pecinta slot online. Kini Joker888 hadir dengan bonus yang lebih berlimpah lagi dan jackpot yang tidak henti-hentinya diberikan oleh Joker888. Sebagai agen Joker888, kami mengadakan event setiap minggunya di permainan Situs Joker888 untuk berbagi jackpot yang memiliki nilai hingga puluhan juta rupiah. Jackpot tersebut sangat mudah untuk didapatkan bagi para pecinta Situs Joker888. Syarat yang mudah dipenuhi membuat banyak bettor Joker888 ingin langsung segera daftar Joker888 di DepoBos.

Situs Joker888

situs poker online said...

The dealer is the one who manages online poker games, with more people who are fond of poker more and more new dealers are appearing. Poker book listings will help you find trusted dealers that can be used as a place to play bets that are safe and comfortable. It is undeniable that players in Indonesia are very happy with a game that can make a profit. While playing bets in Indonesian is prohibited, playing online is chosen by many players so that the risk is smaller,

situs poker online
situs poker online
situs poker online

situs poker online said...

The dealer is the one who manages online poker games, with more people who are fond of poker more and more new dealers are appearing. Poker book listings will help you find trusted dealers that can be used as a place to play bets that are safe and comfortable. It is undeniable that players in Indonesia are very happy with a game that can make a profit. While playing bets in Indonesian is prohibited, playing online is chosen by many players so that the risk is smaller,

situs poker online
situs poker online
situs poker online

situs poker online said...

The dealer is the one who manages online poker games, with more people who are fond of poker more and more new dealers are appearing. Poker book listings will help you find trusted dealers that can be used as a place to play bets that are safe and comfortable. It is undeniable that players in Indonesia are very happy with a game that can make a profit. While playing bets in Indonesian is prohibited, playing online is chosen by many players so that the risk is smaller,

situs poker online
situs poker online
situs poker online

Anonymous said...

joker388
joker388
joker388

joker388 said...

joker388
joker388
joker388

joker388 said...

joker388
joker388
joker388

joker388 said...

joker388
joker388
joker388

joker388 said...

joker388
joker388
joker388

judi online said...

Permainan yang mudah tidak selalu mengacu pada bentuk permainan judi yang mudah. Permainan di situs poker online akan memiliki tingkat kesulitan yang cukup baik. Berbagai situasi dalam penggunaan permainan Judi online ini akan membuat sejumlah permainan Judi online menjadi lebih mudah dimainkan.

judi online said...

Easy games don't always refer to easy forms of gambling. Games on online poker sites will have a fairly good difficulty level. Various situations in the use of gambling games will make a number of gambling games easier to play.

judi online said...

Easy games don't always refer to easy forms of gambling. Games on online poker sites will have a fairly good difficulty level.

Judi online
Judi online
Judi online

judi online said...

Easy games don't always refer to easy forms of gambling. Games on online poker sites will have a fairly good difficulty level.

Judi online
Judi online
Judi online

judi online said...

Easy games don't always refer to easy forms of gambling. Games on online poker sites will have a fairly good difficulty level.


Judi online
Judi online
Judi online

joker1888 said...

If you want to Register for Fish Shoot, don't hesitate to contact Whatsapp or Livechat. Because Joker1888 provides Original Fish Shoot Money Gambling by several well-known providers such as CQ9, Spadegaming and Joker123. The Fish Shoot game is currently very popular because it provides a very high victory rate. Of course this Fish Shoot Gambling Game provides a different sensation for you online gambling players.

agen Joker1888 said...

If you want to Register for Fish Shoot, don't hesitate to contact Whatsapp or Livechat. Because agen Joker1888 provides Original Fish Shoot Money Gambling by several well-known providers such as CQ9, Spadegaming and Joker123. The Fish Shoot game is currently very popular because it provides a very high victory rate. Of course this Fish Shoot Gambling Game provides a different sensation for you online gambling players.

joker1788 said...

Joker1788 Situs judi slot mesin online uang asli dan live casino online terbesar di Indonesia. Agen Slot Online Joker1788 menyediakan ratusan permainan judi slot online terbaik dan live casino online dengan minimal taruhan yang terjangkau untuk semua kalangan yang baru bermain Slot Online Uang Asli. Selain itu kami juga menyediakan produk Taruhan Tembak Ikan Online Uang Asli.

joker128 said...

DepoBos is the safest and most trusted online gambler and fish shooting gambling agent in Asia. Depobos as the provider for its main website is Joker128 which has many online slot games or Indonesian Fish Shoot games online. Available in the form of applications or can be played on the desktop with good and clear picture quality, we indulge slot game lovers in Indonesia to play comfortably on their cellphones or computers.
Joker128
Joker128
Joker128
Joker128
Joker128
Joker128
Joker128
Joker128
Joker128
Joker128
Joker128
Joker128

fafaslot said...

The Fafaslot site provides many variations of online slot games where steps to play and win are very easy. In addition to online slots, this application includes providing other games such as online fish shooting, live casino and mini games and you can play them together using only a user ID.

fafaslot
fafaslot
fafaslot

fafaslot said...


The Fafaslot site provides many variations of online slot games where steps to play and win are very easy. In addition to online slots, this application includes providing other games such as online fish shooting, live casino and mini games and you can play them together using only a user ID.

fafaslot
fafaslot
fafaslot

Joker368 said...

Joker368
Joker368
Joker368
Joker368
Joker368
Joker368
Joker368
Joker368
Joker368

fafaslot said...

The Fafaslot site provides many variations of online slot games where steps to play and win are very easy. In addition to online slots, this application includes providing other games such as online fish shooting, live casino and mini games and you can play them together using only a user ID.

fafaslot
fafaslot
fafaslot

fafaslot said...

The Fafaslot site provides many variations of online slot games where steps to play and win are very easy. In addition to online slots, this application includes providing other games such as online fish shooting, live casino and mini games and you can play them together using only a user ID.

fafaslot
fafaslot
fafaslot

fafaslot said...

The Fafaslot site provides many variations of online slot games where steps to play and win are very easy. In addition to online slots, this application includes providing other games such as online fish shooting, live casino and mini games and you can play them together using only a user ID.

fafaslot
fafaslot
fafaslot

joker7788 said...

joker7788 has friendly and professional customer services that are ready to serve you 24/7 24/7. joker7788 We are also supported by 5 Big Banks in Indonesia, including BCA, Mandiri, BNI, BRI and CIMB Niaga and Danamon, to facilitate your transaction process. joker7788

fafaslot said...


The Fafaslot site provides many variations of online slot games where steps to play and win are very easy. In addition to online slots, this application includes providing other games such as online fish shooting, live casino and mini games and you can play them together using only a user ID.

fafaslot
fafaslot
fafaslot

judi poker said...

Judi Poker

Judi Poker

Judi Poker

Judi Poker

Judi Poker

Judi poker said...

It's a good thing you found this article. The cause below we will review the promised steps of play with full victory, which is high from the 5 best-selling gamblings games in Indonesia.
Judi poker

Judi poker said...

It's a good thing you found this article. The cause below we will review the promised steps of play with full victory, which is high from the 5 best-selling gamblings games in Indonesia.

Judi poker
Judi poker
Judi poker

Judi poker said...

It's a good thing you found this article. The cause below we will review the promised steps of play with full victory, which is high from the 5 best-selling gamblings games in Indonesia.

[url=https://speakerdeck.com/cisneros2351] Judi poker[/url]

[url=https://www.cosplayisland.co.uk/user/66909] Judi poker[/url]

[url=https://www.tor.com/members/cisneros2351/] Judi poker[/url]

Judi poker said...

It's a good thing you found this article. The cause below we will review the promised steps of play with full victory, which is high from the 5 best-selling gamblings games in Indonesia.

Judi poker

Judi poker

Judi poker

Unknown said...

joker688
joker688
joker688
joker688
joker688
joker688
joker688
joker688
joker688
joker688
joker688
joker688
joker688
joker688
joker688
joker688
joker688
joker688

joker8899 said...


daftar joker8899 juga menyediakan permainan live casino online yang terdiri dari 5 Provider Terbaik dan Terbesar di Asia maupun Eropa seperti ASIAGAMING, ALLBET, EBET, EVOLUTIONGAMING dan SAGAMING.

joker8899 said...

joker8899 also provides online live casino games consisting of the 5 Best and Largest Providers in Asia and Europe such as ASIAGAMING, ALLBET, EBET, EVOLUTIONGAMING and SAGAMING.

joker8899

joker8899

joker8899

Joker8868 said...

We as joker8868 agents continue to provide the most professional, attractive and satisfying online entertainment for our loyal members, with the best service, the best game deals, and highly professional staff in a safe and comfortable environment. We provide list joker8868 services, joker8868 deposit, download joker8868, login joker8868 and alternative link joker8868. Joker8868

BClub said...

You’re so cool! I do not believe I’ve read anything like that before. So great to discover somebody with some original thoughts on this subject matter. Seriously.. many thanks for starting this up. This web site is one thing that’s needed on the web, someone with some originality!
Agen Bola Terfavorit
Taruhan Bola Terfavorit
Kasino Online Terlengkap
bandar Kasino Online Terlengkap

kayplummer9916 said...

We as joker8868 agents continue to provide the most professional, attractive and satisfying online entertainment for our loyal members, with the best service, the best game deals, and highly professional staff in a safe and comfortable environment. We provide list joker8868 services, joker8868 deposit, download joker8868, login joker8868 and alternative link joker8868. http://51.79.171.76/

Unknown said...

JOKERINDO merupakan salah satu Situs Judi Online dan Agen Slot Game, yang telah melayani para bettor sejati selama bertahun-tahun. Jokerindo Terpercaya karena merupakan salah satu yang terbaik di Asia, kualitas dan integritas membawa kami untuk selalu mengembangkan sayap di beberapa negara Asia seperti Indonesia Sebagai Taruhan Bola ataupun Slot Game Terbaik sepanjang masa. Daftar dan bermain bersama Bandar Judi Slot Game Bersama Jokerindo Sekarang.

poker online said...

Now is the time to answer if you want to win then you also have to be prepared to face defeat in betting. So indeed many of you really need to know how to play first.
Poker online

poker online said...

Poker online Now is the time to answer if you want to win then you also have to be prepared to face defeat in betting.

poker online said...

Now is the time to answer if you want to win then you also have to be prepared to face defeat in betting.

Poker online
Poker online
Poker online
Poker online

joker8899 said...

joker8899
joker8899
joker8899
joker8899
joker8899
joker8899
joker8899
joker8899
joker8899
joker8899
joker8899
joker8899
joker8899
joker8899
joker8899

Judi online said...

So bets are now more attractive. If you play or understand the lottery game carefully, the process of winning will be a little easier. Only lottery betting games have many types of games, so you also need to be very serious. Because every online lottery betting game is very attractive to you all.
Judi online

Judi online said...

So bets are now more attractive. If you play or understand the lottery game carefully, the process of winning will be a little easier. Only lottery betting games have many types of games, so you also need to be very serious. Because every online lottery betting game is very attractive to you all.
Judi online

Judi online said...

So bets are now more attractive. If you play or understand the lottery game carefully, the process of winning will be a little easier.

Judi online
Judi online
Judi online
Judi online

Jokerwin123 said...

Jokerwin123 deposit 50000 pakai ovo saat ini dapat Anda gunakan untuk melakukan deposit ke akun jokerwin123 Anda. Caranya sangat mudah, yaitu Anda hanya perlu melakukan penarikan dana dari akun OVO Anda dan kirimkan ke bank BCA tujuan deposit kami nantinya. Jokerwin123

Unknown said...

Jokerwin123 50000 deposit using ovo now you can use to make a deposit to your jokerwin123 account. The method is very easy, that is, you only need to withdraw funds from your OVO account and send it to the BCA bank for the purpose of our deposit later. http://51.79.171.79/

artikel judi said...

Speaking of artikel judi, we need to know some interesting facts about the growth of online gambling itself. This time, we will introduce interesting facts about online gambling that are so popular in many countries in the world.

artikel judi said...

Speaking of artikel judi, we need to know some interesting facts about the growth of online gambling itself. This time, we will introduce interesting facts about online gambling.

artikel judi said...

Speaking of online gambling, we need to know some interesting facts about the growth of online gambling itself. This time, we will introduce interesting facts about online gambling.

artikel judi
artikel judi
artikel judi
artikel judi

joker7878 said...

joker7878 is one of the Online Gambling Sites and Slot Game Agents, which has been serving true bettor for years. Joker7878 Trusted because it is one of the best in Asia, quality and integrity lead us to always develop wings in several Asian countries such as Indonesia as the Best Ball Betting or Slot Game of all time. Register and play with Bandar Judi Slot Game with joker7878 Now.

Vivoslot said...

vivoslot terus berupaya memberikan hiburan online yang paling profesional, menarik, dan memuaskan bagi para member setia, dengan layanan terbaik, menawarkan permainan terbaik, dan staf yang sangat profesional di lingkungan yang aman dan nyaman. Vivoslot

kameronmayo said...

vivoslot terus berupaya memberikan hiburan online yang paling profesional, menarik, dan memuaskan bagi para member setia, dengan layanan terbaik, menawarkan permainan terbaik, dan staf yang sangat profesional di lingkungan yang aman dan nyaman. http://51.79.184.83/

shokatais4185 said...

Di samping itu, situs judi online anda bolehh mencoba untuk meramal kan nomor pada ke dua dua dadu, jadi kesempatan menang ialah lebih besar. Tetapi atas karena ini, kami memiliki kesempatan yg lbh baik untuk menang.

cara bermain poker said...

Benefits of Sicbo Online Gambling in Indonesia. There are many ways to try online gambling games online. Sic Bo is a game that many people love. Because this era of technology is so modern, we cannot play the game on its own through cellular or cellular networks.
cara bermain poker

cara bermain poker said...

Benefits of Sicbo Online Gambling in Indonesia. There are many ways to try online gambling games online. Sic Bo is a game that many people love. Because this era of technology is so modern, we cannot play the game on its own through cellular or cellular networks.
cara bermain poker

Cara Bermain Poker said...

Because this era of technology is so modern, we cannot play the game on its own through cellular or cellular networks.

Cara Bermain Poker
Cara Bermain Poker
Cara Bermain Poker
Cara Bermain Poker

Unknown said...

Online gambling games that have various types of games are certainly very interesting. From all about online gambling games that are played online which of course has a different chance of winning each.

agen idn poker

Unknown said...

Talking about progress for victory is certainly not easy to obtain. So behind all of this by wanting to achieve victory and profit, of course, are required to have tricks and accurate strategies.

idn poker
agen bandarq
situs poker online

Unknown said...

This guide will summarize some easy ways about winning tricks or strategies that you can use every day. Surely from this trick is very easy for you to do.

bandar poker online
agen poker online
agen domino qiu qiu
situs judi poker qq

Joker1999 said...

Joker1999 merupakan agen resmi dari Joker Gaming, salah satu bandar penyedia layanan judi slot online yang paling populer di antara pemain dari Indonesia. Selain permainan judi slot, kami juga memiliki berbagai taruhan Sportsbook Online terkini.
Joker1999

heatherclark7918 said...

Joker1999 merupakan agen resmi dari Joker Gaming, salah satu bandar penyedia layanan judi slot online yang paling populer di antara pemain dari Indonesia. Selain permainan judi slot, kami juga memiliki berbagai taruhan Sportsbook Online terkini. http://51.81.73.53/

Unknown said...

The consequence you receive from this error is that the first time you experience defeat for your ignorance of the game.

judi poker online
situs judi poker qq
agen sbobet resmi
agen sbobet terpercaya

Unknown said...

Gambling betting games should be played very carefully, which means that when playing with the emotions that accompany you, of course, that there is actually plunging you into defeat.

agen sbobet terpercaya
situs agen judi bola
situs bandar judi online
agen sbobet terpercaya
agen judi sbobet

cahrubelle1330 said...

Tetapi judi online kita memiliki sedikit ke menangan. Brbanding taruhan tiga dadu kami, tdk kira jika kami brsedia untuk mendapatkan bonus kecil. Satu taruhan nombor tunggal ialah taruhan gampang,

RatuBola303 said...

Hi thanks for ur blog, its great please visit back my site at Ratubola303 & Agen Bola Terpercaya

Unknown said...

The list of trusted and best official online football betting agents can deposit ovo pulses from Indonesia.

situs judi bola online
situs poker online terpercaya
agen judi bola sbobet
agen sbobet
agen sbobet

Judi online said...

You have chosen one of the three dice that we believe has a chance of winning. At the end, the leader will be shaken. If you shake the dice, the leader will designate the results of the dice.
Judi online

Judi online said...

At the end, the leader will be shaken. If you shake the dice, the leader will designate the results of the dice.
Judi online

Judi online said...

At the end, the leader will be shaken. If you shake the dice, the leader will designate the results of the dice.

Judi online
Judi online
Judi online
Judi online